PIECE
STATUS
COMPLETE
VOLUMES
10
RELEASE
April 13, 2013
CHAPTERS
21
DESCRIPTION
One day, Mizuho, a university student, receives news that her classmate in high school, Origuchi Haruka, passed away. Mizuho doesn’t remember being best friends with Origuchi, but apparently, Origuchi told her mother that Mizuho was her best friend. And now, her mother wants Mizuho to help her find the boy Origuchi dated during high school. Mizuho told Origuchi’s mother that Origuchi was a very plain girl, and she was never seen with a guy, but her mother told Mizuho that Origuchi got pregnant and had an abortion when she was in high school. Mizuho was shocked, so she starts asking her other classmates in high school and following the traces Origuchi left behind.
CAST
Mizuho Suga
CHAPTERS
REVIEWS
lennix
100/100Your ripped up pride can be reconstructed slowly day by day, you just need to gather up the pieces.Continue on AniListI want to start off by saying that Piece absolutely blew my socks off. While some of the events may fall into the realm of melodrama, it is the reactions these characters have in response to these events that makes this manga so special. It doesn't feel forced at all, each action taken is one I fully believe a real person would make, both the good and the bad. I appreciate how Piece doesn't cut any corners, instead it lays all bare and leaves it's characters to pick up the pieces. Alright lets get into to why I love it so much.
Everything you need to understand about this manga can be found in the title. It's quite an elegant straightforward yet effective visual metaphor; pieces of the overarching mystery, but also of the broken people within it, pieces of the human heart and soul. It finds a balance right on the sweet spot between thematic depth and accessibility, and I just love that. Piece, quite literally, is a story about uncovering the past, about understanding where, why, and how things came to be as they are. While the majority of the narrative is about delving into the past, Piece is sharply focused on the here and now, on who these characters are at this moment in time. It's not about who you were in the past or who you may be in the future, it's about coming to terms with yourself in the present in spite of all the baggage and anxiety that you may carry. The problem is, this is much easier said than done. If self-introspection was easy this world would be a much different place.
So what's the answer? Of course the answer lies in others, the people around us who influence us, those we rely on. As they say 'no man is an island.' Even still, putting things into practice is a bit difficult. This is where Piece really left an impact on me. I relate hard to those "I want to know", "I'm scared to know", "I want to look away", "I'm afraid to take step and step on a landmine" feelings that Mizuho has throughout the manga. It masterfully captures how another person can worm their way into your mind, causing you to "look away" by putting a label on them to avoid facing the invasive presence they've become in your mind, and yet no matter how much you try to deny it you still "want to know." Looking, truly looking at others and yourself might be the most painful thing you do. To get on your hands and knees dig for something, anything to help you genuinely reach those you care about, it's going to hurt. Sure you may "step on a landmine" or make yourself and others uncomfortable for a time, you may even feel as if you've been left by the wayside. But that's okay, you can't be perfect all of a sudden. Your ripped up pride can be reconstructed slowly day by day, you just need to gather up the pieces.
bazazilio
100/100we are scared of resonance, yet we crave it anywayContinue on AniListI doubt you'd be surprised if someone told you something like "all people have their own stories" or "everyone is a unique individual". Duh. We've all heard it so many times before. However, Piece executes this idea so perfectly that it feels weirdly novel. Not only does the manga show us how complex humans actually are, but it also explores why we sometimes refuse to see that complexity and instead choose to reduce people around us to cliches we can understand. Because the resonance that comes from understanding the complexity of another human being can make us feel all sorts of unpleasant things.
Piece follows Suga Mizuho, a "cold, heartless person", who doesn't get too close to people and doesn't let anyone in. She doesn't let herself be affected by people or life events; she keeps her distance and does her own thing. Yet when the mother of her dead former classmate, Origuchi Haruka, asks her to find her daughter's high school boyfriend who got her pregnant, Mizuho somehow decides to get involved. Because everyone vaguely remembers Origuchi as a quiet girl with no friends, Mizuho finds it hard to believe that she had a boyfriend at all. So maybe that's why she feels almost compelled to follow the trail of small pieces of memory that Origuchi left behind.
The story would have been good enough if it was just about Origuchi, a dead girl people barely remember. But it's a lot more than that. It begins with morbid curiosity about the private life of a dead girl, but that only serves as bait to lure us along with Mizuho into a complex web of characters that were connected to Origuchi. Led by her desire to know what her classmate was "really like", Mizuho is forced to collide with other people and get close to them to the point of being uncomfortable.
I think that Piece is ultimately a story about resonance. The shock of resonance that is created when we choose to really get to know another human being instead of looking away and keeping our distance. People are empathic beings, which is why when we satisfy our craving to get closer to another person, it always hits us back. When we learn something deep and personal about someone, we don't gain impartial "objective" knowledge; instead, we find a point of connection, of resonance that can't leave us unaffected. And yet before, Mizuho was trying to go through life strong, calm, and unaffected, without "feeling anything unpleasant or making others feel that way." But she eventually gives in to the temptation to peek at things that are too close and personal because she also craves that connection, that resonance. Even though it will definitely make everyone involved feel something unpleasant because it just feels too close for comfort.
Because Mizuho knows that true familiarity is bound to shake her up, she keeps her distance by reducing people to cliches she can understand. She thinks things like "that girl is always smiling" or "he doesn't feel any sort of emotion" or "she is ordinary, there is nothing special about her". Of course, it is much easier for Mizuho to maintain composure when people around her are neatly sorted into categories. At least that way, they definitely won't get into her head. And because we see the other characters through the eyes of Mizuho, who is looking away from them, we are masterfully manipulated into giving all of them a couple of labels of our own, all based on our reading expectations.
It's not like Mizuho's fears are unwarranted, though. True resonance is actually unpleasant. No, I mean it. I feel like we have this idealistic idea about opening up and getting close to people, like "it's difficult, but you'll feel better about it" sort of thing. Like we're supposed to just open up to each other, then hold hands and become friends or lovers for life. But Piece reflects how, in reality, that doesn't always happen. Opening up brings some people closer and drives others apart. It makes sense because seeing other people's ugliness and vulnerability and showing them your own fair share of ugliness and vulnerability is very embarrassing in the first place, and afterwards being in the company of those who know your darkest secrets can be very awkward and uncomfortable. And of course, there are some dark secrets and ugliness that you can't accept, no matter how hard you try.
But it is still worth the risk.
It's better than knowing that something is wrong but deciding not to ask unnecessary questions, better than seeing that someone is in trouble but looking away because it's none of your business. All because you don't want to feel uncomfortable or make anyone feel that way. Too afraid to take the wrong step and step on a landmine, to make other people hate you for asking questions, for trying to help, for doing unnecessary things. Thinking that at least if no one is uncomfortable, you can keep your fake relationship and fake calm, at least you won't drive anyone away. It's always better to be a cringy idiot ready to die of embarrassment than to let other people suffer only to protect your perfect facade of calm.
But the sad thing is, you can ask all the uncomfortable questions, be brave and embarrassed, get close, uncomfortably close, get wrecked by the resonance, and still not know what that person is "really" like. Because in the end, all you have is your own perception of them, and "no one will get hurt", even if you mould your image of them into one that feels comfortable enough. So the story is cruel in a way, encouraging us all to go looking for something we can never really attain — the soul of another human being.
Anyways, I feel like this review is becoming more and more abstract the longer I write it because I'm trying to keep it spoiler-free. I didn't even mention the characters that made the most impact on me, all because I want you to just go into Piece blind, without any pre-conceived notions about which characters are important and which are not. Just go read it and be surprised.
But imagine one manga making you think all these unnecessary thoughts, haha.
yukari1230
80/100I have some conflict in my heart and maybe that's what the author wanted you to feel.Continue on AniListI'll divide this review into two parts. The first part is just the emotional impact this story had on me, and the second would be a more somewhat objective recommendation of sorts. I think that not everyone will like this story, in fact I have some mixed feelings that really frustrate me but from just a narrative point of view I can appreciate it for what it is. The second part is for people who want to just know whether the story will be for them or not. I will try to keep the second part spoiler-free the very least, but not the first part.
Anyway, let's proceed to how I feel about this story.
I didn't come into this knowing the author was the same one as Sand Chronicles. Sand Chronicles is a manga quite dear to my heart but once I noticed the artstyle which I immediately recognized upon reading the first chapter, I immediately had certain expectations going in. Sand Chronicles was a whole roller coaster of emotions and with an ending....I can't say I was entirely happy with but was realistic but also made sense.
I think that Piece has a lot of questionable things happening but I think it's more of a testament of the time this was written in and the biases society has in the first place.
I can really just say that I think the part I am actually conflicted by the most....are not Narumi's mother getting scot free for being a bitch who experimented with her own children like that or the open ending where we don't have closure between Narumi and Mizuho, but that MIZUHO JUST FORGAVE HER EX LIKE THAT AND EVEN THANKED HIM.
Like I know that the point was to show that Mizuho wasn't concerning herself with people and also was not conveying her emotions at all. The whole story is her trying to combat this all this time and to find a send of her own self. She also thinks about the way we stay with other people and how we influence each other - how we leave a 'piece' in each other's lives (which circles back to the name of the manga).
BUT while I know we kinda get that Mizuho has sort of accepted things the way they are, I wish she could have gotten angry at her cheating ex, cussed him out the very least. I guess they thanked each other for some sort of closure but it somehow justifies that he still hurt her even if she wasn't super affected in the end. And that just pisses me off lmao. I mean yes, I know she sort of has no self-respect for herself in regards to Narumi, I'm frustrated nonetheless because at least it's more of "If I'm trash, would you still love me" and her answer to that is "Yes" and we know that Narumi is sort of following what Hiro did in trying to become better (Hiro wanted to become better before he showed himself to Origuchi again but well we know how that turns out). Mizuho has said everything that needs to be said for that!! But she never really acknowledged how she was wronged....also no confrontation with her dad.
Is this because I really don't like infidelity tropes? Perhaps. But it's like watching someone go thru all these revelations but in that regards she did nothing dfjfuvbdjf Girl, realize that you did deserve better...you had your failings and things you lacked, but it doesn't excuse him cheating on you all the same, you know?
For the Narumi mother...I knew we would never get any real closure with her. That was the point of her character - a horrible person who thinks she knows better than anyone and thinks she's better than everyone. I hate her yeah but I never expected something to happen to her since the story wasn't about justice to the Narumi brothers so much as to how they got fucked up but still had to learn how to live after the kind of lives they had. It does frustrate me but I never expected anything from her.
And despite this we go back to I think there's a bit of this social pressure to forgive other people and that it will help you and help you forgive yourself...I don't agree with that kind of ideology so the author and I will just not agree on that aspect I suppose.
Does this make the story bad? No. Let's get into the 2nd part.
Who is this story for? If you want an emotional story full of flawed characters, some with quite narrow mindsets, this is a good one. If you're here for the mystery....I think it's more of an add-on if you like that sort of thing like I do, but the human connection is the primary theme of this story more than anything. I think that this is truly a story written after decades of life experience. The whole picture is something I can appreciate looking at it through the lens of someone almost the age of 30. I don't think I would have enjoyed this as much if I read it in my mid-teens.
Who is this story not for? There are lots of unlikable things about each characters. Honestly, if wanted to cheer for people...this isn't the story for that. This is a lot about learning about yourself and others and how it's almost never a pretty picture. Even I got really frustrated with some aspects of it but I also reminded myself what the main point of the story was. You will definitely disagree with some of the actions of the characters and that's ok.
Anyway, I think a story that can make you strongly feel is a good one nonetheless.
Sidenote: Man, they had so much money to ride the shinkansen so many times lmao. They talk about being broke but like WHERE DO YOU STILL GET THAT MONEY FROM YOU GUYS ARE LIKE 19
SIMILAR MANGAS YOU MAY LIKE
MANGA DramaHaru no Noroi
MANGA DramaCoelacanth
MANGA DramaOboreru Knife
SCORE
- (3.7/5)
MORE INFO
Ended inApril 13, 2013
Favorited by 50 Users